A day or three ago, ABC News reported that red wine and chocolate “are cancer killers”. But nothing in the ABC’s report gave any idea of how strong was this evidence, or what practical use the information has.
The ABC reported that the news had come from “Angiogenesis Foundation head William Li told a TED (technology, entertainment design) conference in Long Beach, California.”
The Ted 2010 conference listed Dr William Li as a ‘cancer researcher’ from the ‘Angiogenesis Foundation, a nonprofit that is re-conceptualizing global disease fighting’. His speech was on 10 February 2010. The TED conference published a slide from Dr Li’s presentation that lists ‘Dietary sources of naturally-occuring angiogenic substances’:

The list certainly includes both red wine and chocolate. Let’s see if we can trace the sources of information back to original research.
1. Red wine
The only reference I can find to “red wine” at the site of the Angiogenesis Foundation is in an article from May 2009, ‘Antiangiogenic Substances in Blackberries, Licorice May Aid Cancer Prevention’. From the title, I can guess that this is not about “cancer killers” but about cancer prevention. The article states:
…researchers at the Ohio State Comprehensive Cancer Center found that anthocyanins, a class of flavonoids present in many types of berries, as well as red wine, inhibited tumor growth and angiogenesis, and stimulated cancer cell death in the experimental rats treated with a potent esophageal carcinogen.
The Ohio State Comprehensive Cancer Center’s article is Wang L-S, Hecht SS, Carmella SG, et al. ‘Anthocyanins in black raspberries prevent esophageal tumors in rats’. Cancer Prev Res 2009;2(1):84-93. The abstract tells us that the researchers gave rats a substance expected to induce cancer of the esophagus, then fed the rats on various diets including extracts from freeze-dried black raspberries (BRB). They concluded that “the anthocyanins in BRB have chemopreventive potential” and also that “components other than berry anthocyanins may be chemopreventive”.
So far as I can see, the article doesn’t mention red wine. But perhaps the Angiogenesis Foundation was extrapolating. That is, the research discovered something about anthocyanins in freeze-dried black raspberries. And, separate from the research, the Angiogenesis Foundation observes that anthocyanins are present in berries and in red wine. Since I wouldn’t know an anthocyanin if I fell over one in the street, I can’t tell.
The Angiogenesis Foundation’s article goes on:
In the second study related to dietary antiangiogenesis, researchers at Vanderbilt University Medical Center showed that inhibiting an enzyme called 11β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type 2 (11βHSD2) by treatment with a natural compound found in licorice prevents colorectal cancer progression in mice.
The study is Zhang M-Z, Xu J, Yao B, et al. ‘Inhibition of 11b–hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type II selectively blocks the tumor COX-2 pathway and suppresses colon carcinogenesis in mice and humans.’ J Clin Invest 2009;119:876-885. It’s about colorectal cancer in mice and people.
I understand ‘licorice’. The rest of the abstract is several steps beyond my capacity to understand. But I’m sure I’d recognize the phrase “drink red wine and your cancer will go away” if I saw it.
2. Chocolate
Google can’t find any use of the word ‘chocolate’ at the angio.org site.

So this is a dead end. I can’t find what research led Dr Li to the chocolate conclusion.
My conclusion
I’ve traced back the reference to red wine, and failed to find a reference to chocolate at Dr Li’s site at angio.org. From this, we now know that:
- Rats who were given a known carcinogen and then ate freeze-dried black raspberries didn’t get as many oesophageal tumours as those who didn’t eat freeze-dried raspberries.
- Something in licorice inhibits an enzyme and doing so prevents colorectal cancer progression in mice.
I’m not sure how this leads to the breathless headline “Red wine and chocolate ‘are cancer killers’”.